User avatar
MKIIProductions
Registered User
Registered User
Posts: 426
Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2010 4:31 pm
Real Name: Jacob Green
YouTube Username: MKIIProductions
Discord: ncognito#6466
Location: All over the place
Contact: Facebook

Wed Feb 23, 2011 8:21 pm

I find it odd that they'd even bother to run a siren on gasoline. I can see that it might have been cheaper in the 50s, 60s and 70s but Gas prices have skyrocketed from this BP mess and Propane is more of the same. I'd just stick with 240 volts of sheer 3 phase electricity. :wink: I have had my encounters, with 120 volts, not 240... yet. :mrgreen:
But Running a siren such as the Thunderbolt, Let alone the Mobil Directo on Gas would be unbelivably expensive in these times of economy. I can see where they got the idea of running a siren on Gas, since electricity was "Dangerous" back then. But hey, If it was a good alternative to electricity, I can see that it may be cheaper, but I also see gas as more of a "Fire Hazard" than electricity.
The unofficial ARS resident white noise since 2010
http://www.youtube.com/MKIIProductions
Jacob Green - 25, Wichita, Kansas
You can buy any radio you want, just don't buy a Baofeng and call it a scanner.

ONLY YOU CAN PREVENT MALICIOUS ACTIVATIONS

User avatar
Mac
Registered User
Registered User
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2009 2:52 pm
Location: Durham, NC

Wed Feb 23, 2011 9:39 pm

MKIIProductions wrote:I find it odd that they'd even bother to run a siren on gasoline. I can see that it might have been cheaper in the 50s, 60s and 70s but Gas prices have skyrocketed from this BP mess and Propane is more of the same. I'd just stick with 240 volts of sheer 3 phase electricity. :wink: I have had my encounters, with 120 volts, not 240... yet. :mrgreen:
But Running a siren such as the Thunderbolt, Let alone the Mobil Directo on Gas would be unbelivably expensive in these times of economy. I can see where they got the idea of running a siren on Gas, since electricity was "Dangerous" back then. But hey, If it was a good alternative to electricity, I can see that it may be cheaper, but I also see gas as more of a "Fire Hazard" than electricity.
I don't think it has anything to do with the efficiency, cost, or danger to run the siren, but the availability of power. Not everywhere that needs a siren has the resources to power it, that is were gas or propane can come in. Takes a whole lot of juice to power up some of this stuff.

When the power goes out, an all gas siren (though from the sounds of it, the the previous reason seems to be more likely with the thunderbolt) will still roar. Think of it like an old school DC siren.
Sterling M-5, Sterling Mechanical Siren Timer, Federal Electric Co. Type B, Federal C3 1/2, Secomak VS1, Federal Type A (Coded & Standard), AF Timer, various other sirens \ controls

User avatar
JasonC
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 3444
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 5:49 pm
YouTube Username: Jsncrso
Location: OBX, NC

Thu Feb 24, 2011 4:09 am

MKIIProductions wrote:I find it odd that they'd even bother to run a siren on gasoline. I can see that it might have been cheaper in the 50s, 60s and 70s but Gas prices have skyrocketed from this BP mess and Propane is more of the same. I'd just stick with 240 volts of sheer 3 phase electricity. :wink: I have had my encounters, with 120 volts, not 240... yet. :mrgreen:
But Running a siren such as the Thunderbolt, Let alone the Mobil Directo on Gas would be unbelivably expensive in these times of economy. I can see where they got the idea of running a siren on Gas, since electricity was "Dangerous" back then. But hey, If it was a good alternative to electricity, I can see that it may be cheaper, but I also see gas as more of a "Fire Hazard" than electricity.
Please don't take this the wrong way (not trying to be mean or anything) but none of that makes any sense. It would take only a few cents of gasoline to run the siren for a full cycle. And electricity being "dangerous" had absolutely nothing to do with it (that's back from the 1800's, not the 50's). It was simply an option for locations which couldn't supply a large electrical load (think plugging in an entire thunderbolt into a wall socket). And a fire hazard is pretty much nill. With that being said however, a 3-phase thunderbolt is definitely your best bet.

User avatar
MKIIProductions
Registered User
Registered User
Posts: 426
Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2010 4:31 pm
Real Name: Jacob Green
YouTube Username: MKIIProductions
Discord: ncognito#6466
Location: All over the place
Contact: Facebook

Thu Feb 24, 2011 3:11 pm

JasonC wrote:
MKIIProductions wrote:I find it odd that they'd even bother to run a siren on gasoline. I can see that it might have been cheaper in the 50s, 60s and 70s but Gas prices have skyrocketed from this BP mess and Propane is more of the same. I'd just stick with 240 volts of sheer 3 phase electricity. :wink: I have had my encounters, with 120 volts, not 240... yet. :mrgreen:
But Running a siren such as the Thunderbolt, Let alone the Mobil Directo on Gas would be unbelivably expensive in these times of economy. I can see where they got the idea of running a siren on Gas, since electricity was "Dangerous" back then. But hey, If it was a good alternative to electricity, I can see that it may be cheaper, but I also see gas as more of a "Fire Hazard" than electricity.
Please don't take this the wrong way (not trying to be mean or anything) but none of that makes any sense. It would take only a few cents of gasoline to run the siren for a full cycle. And electricity being "dangerous" had absolutely nothing to do with it (that's back from the 1800's, not the 50's). It was simply an option for locations which couldn't supply a large electrical load (think plugging in an entire thunderbolt into a wall socket). And a fire hazard is pretty much nill. With that being said however, a 3-phase thunderbolt is definitely your best bet.
I can see where you come from with that, And i have no problem with what you're saying. But from what I've heard Gas Powered sirens didn't do too well in the market, and in these times of economy it would cost a bit more to run the sirens on gas, given everyone's financial situations here, Especially the county's situations.
The unofficial ARS resident white noise since 2010
http://www.youtube.com/MKIIProductions
Jacob Green - 25, Wichita, Kansas
You can buy any radio you want, just don't buy a Baofeng and call it a scanner.

ONLY YOU CAN PREVENT MALICIOUS ACTIVATIONS

User avatar
MKIIProductions
Registered User
Registered User
Posts: 426
Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2010 4:31 pm
Real Name: Jacob Green
YouTube Username: MKIIProductions
Discord: ncognito#6466
Location: All over the place
Contact: Facebook

Thu Feb 24, 2011 3:15 pm

Mac wrote:
MKIIProductions wrote:I find it odd that they'd even bother to run a siren on gasoline. I can see that it might have been cheaper in the 50s, 60s and 70s but Gas prices have skyrocketed from this BP mess and Propane is more of the same. I'd just stick with 240 volts of sheer 3 phase electricity. :wink: I have had my encounters, with 120 volts, not 240... yet. :mrgreen:
But Running a siren such as the Thunderbolt, Let alone the Mobil Directo on Gas would be unbelivably expensive in these times of economy. I can see where they got the idea of running a siren on Gas, since electricity was "Dangerous" back then. But hey, If it was a good alternative to electricity, I can see that it may be cheaper, but I also see gas as more of a "Fire Hazard" than electricity.
I don't think it has anything to do with the efficiency, cost, or danger to run the siren, but the availability of power. Not everywhere that needs a siren has the resources to power it, that is were gas or propane can come in. Takes a whole lot of juice to power up some of this stuff.

When the power goes out, an all gas siren (though from the sounds of it, the the previous reason seems to be more likely with the thunderbolt) will still roar. Think of it like an old school DC siren.
Yes, that's where a gas powered system comes into play- A power outage. (Completely forgot to cover that in my post, oops.) I can see that's where the system would be more Reliable and accurate. Then there's the challenge of sirens sounding in the unthreatened area.
The unofficial ARS resident white noise since 2010
http://www.youtube.com/MKIIProductions
Jacob Green - 25, Wichita, Kansas
You can buy any radio you want, just don't buy a Baofeng and call it a scanner.

ONLY YOU CAN PREVENT MALICIOUS ACTIVATIONS

User avatar
Nelso90
Registered User
Registered User
Posts: 1025
Joined: Thu May 11, 2006 11:43 pm

Thu Feb 24, 2011 11:06 pm

Given how much operation a siren sees, my hot-rodded snowblower probably uses more gas, and if I can't afford that, well I guess I'm screwed given how much snow we've had here!
No offense, but our FSAE engine on the dyno here at school (KTM 525 turbo) costs WAY more to run than even a Wisconsin V4, and fuel costs are a non-issue.

User avatar
Jim Z
Registered User
Registered User
Posts: 2237
Joined: Tue Aug 01, 2006 1:03 am
Real Name: Jim
Location: ;) or :D are implied

Fri Feb 25, 2011 12:18 am

No offense, but our FSAE engine on the dyno here at school (KTM 525 turbo) costs WAY more to run than even a Wisconsin V4, and fuel costs are a non-issue.
You on the team? I was on our school's team in '98.
MKIIPRoductions wrote:Yes, that's where a gas powered system comes into play- A power outage. (Completely forgot to cover that in my post, oops.) I can see that's where the system would be more Reliable and accurate. Then there's the challenge of sirens sounding in the unthreatened area.
the problem is what with as infrequently as a siren gets used, you have to worry about the gas going stale. if you have service, an engine running on natural gas might be more preferable. no fuel age issues and AFAIK it'd start more reliably in various weather types.

User avatar
JasonC
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 3444
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 5:49 pm
YouTube Username: Jsncrso
Location: OBX, NC

Fri Feb 25, 2011 4:04 am

Gas engines and their controllers have many more points of failure versus an electric motor counterpart. Gas engines are only used when an electric connection isn't feasible.

And running a siren every day would only cost a few bucks a year so gas prices aren't an issue whatsoever, just mere simplicity.

User avatar
SoundOff
Registered User
Registered User
Posts: 518
Joined: Wed May 17, 2006 6:34 pm
Real Name: Andrew Yu
YouTube Username: yuandrew
Location: Chino Hills, CA

Fri Feb 25, 2011 5:37 am

I last saw the San Dimas Thunderbolt 2000 in October of 2009. I didn't have my good camera with me at the time (only my phone) though but I did open up the blower cover again to take a look.

It had an "A" type blower with the large diameter spoked pulley and a 2 cylinder horizontal engine that appeared to be an Onan where you'd normally find the electric motor. I didn't see anything at all that resembled a generator but there was a mysterious looking box with wires coming out mounted over the blower. The box had a single toggle switch on it that could be accessed through a sliding cover on the side of the blower box.

The engine did not appear to be converted to propane or natural gas from what I could see though, it still had the original fuel tank and carburetor. There was some brownish-orange stuff (really stale gas I suppose) in the very bottom of the glass bowl fuel filter under the tank.

I only have 2 good pictures I took that day.

Image

Image
"Calling Out To All"

User avatar
SoundOff
Registered User
Registered User
Posts: 518
Joined: Wed May 17, 2006 6:34 pm
Real Name: Andrew Yu
YouTube Username: yuandrew
Location: Chino Hills, CA

Fri Feb 25, 2011 5:43 am

Some older pictures

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image
(There is a toggle switch accessible under the sliding orange cover)

Image

Image
"Calling Out To All"

Return to “Main Outdoor Warning Sirens Board”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 49 guests